I think you have american gothic for sure... some issue with aliasing could account for the serifs looking a hair different. Or there's a knockoff, but I say go use the original.
I'm kinda shocked but chantel can't be ID'ed on myfonts. Somehow a fairly traditional times/bodoni-looking font never ended up there.
I know that when it became apparent to font companies that they could make legal knockoffs of stuff like helvetica and times new roman for computers, they ended up with tons of clones that had little differences, like times vs nimbus vs dutch801. I think this might be some computer clone of
bodoni, with a few quirks of its own like the "t".