Time is money, faster to slap on some edge caps with silicone and call it a day, they will last 2 years...
True to a point, but if I had a dollar for every customer who told me a
sign only needed to last two years and I saw it out there 5 or 6 or 7 years later still in use, I'd be typing this from my retirement island.
Everybody has their own systems and processes for how they do things. There are a few rights and wrongs to substrate prep and my approach has always to err on the side of better prep and expecting the
sign to ladt longer. I like buying the primed only MDO, sealing and topcoating the way we do and have had good results for many decades doing it that way. To each his own.
To your point, edge capping and silicone cost money too as well as does the labor time to cut and glue in place. I also don't care for the way liberal use of silicone seems to find its way onto other things in the shop we'd rather it not get all over. Or it's negative health effects over time.
The only jobs we treat like temporary ones are for specific events or have a predetermined usage date under three months and specified by the client.