I used to do wholesale Edge printing for a new FastSigns store about a mile from my location before they purchased their own Edge and became pretty good friends with the owner. Our local market had a population of 200K and there were only about 6,000 businesses. There were 52 existing
sign shops. Her background was in sales and management. Her attitude was to do everything FastSigns told her to do.
At the end of her first year, she was grossing $30K a month with two employees.
She received discounts on both equipment and materials that were significantly greater than I was getting as an independent shop ... and I bargain hard for good prices. They were significant enough to cover most of the 6% royalty she was paying. In addition, she got terrific and continuing training for herself and her employees; access to national accounts; product testing; proven marketing materials; and lots more.
After a couple of years, she wanted to open a second store on the other side of town and FastSigns turned her down on the grounds that they did not think the market would support it. Instead they helped her sell her store and purchase a different FastSigns store in a major market that was doing seven figures annually.
Suffice it to say, I have a high opinion of FastSigns as both a capable and respectable franchisor.
She brought good sales and management skills to the table along with a winning attitude. She had no artistic ability or
sign making experience.
The other side of the coin is a success story that was related in some detail on another forum. In this instance, the opposite skill sets were present. The owner was an accomplished artist and
sign maker who, after a number of years, was barely eking out a living. His shortcoming was a lack of sales, marketing and management skills. Instead of closing up, he decided to convert to a franchise shop (not FastSigns). Again, he did what he was told and improved his business from around $100K annually to better than $800K annually in the first year.
I'm sure for every success story there are lots of mediocre stories and some failures among the franchises. You'll have to decide where you think you fit into it all.
Good luck.