QR code - weed this?

[JBurton]

Barcodes are different from QR Codes regarding bits of data that can go missing. Lose one stripe of a bar code and it will be invalid. QR Codes can be generated with certain amounts of error correction built in; they can still work when missing some data spots or when a logo is covering up the middle of the code.

I didn't know this, but had to test it. You can indeed lose a significant amount of small squares and still read the code.

 

[Stacey K]

I didn't know this, but had to test it. You can indeed lose a significant amount of small squares and still read the code.

That's what I would be most worried about...losing some of the squares either from weeding or from weather, etc. Good to know!

 

[damonCA21]

I would worry that if you lost enough of them it would send people to someone elses website

 

[JBurton]

I would worry that if you lost enough of them it would send people to someone elses website

Oddly enough, removing one of the larger squares in the corner made it unreadable, not inaccurate... I guess qr codes have a good parity setup... Well now after reading the wiki article, I'm even more impressed. Also, this poor chap is featured in it (yes, that's two ladders strapped together... at least 2):

 

[dannyd1962]

weed it with a white background as a square and be done with it.....

 

[Bobby H]

Oddly enough, removing one of the larger squares in the corner made it unreadable

The three larger squares in the upper corners and lower left corner are vital; a smartphone camera will use them to properly register angle/orientation before processing the code. There is a common smaller square in the lower right that's always present as well.

The QR Code generator in CorelDRAW provides choices for four levels of error correction: high, low, medium and quartile. Obviously the high setting will mean more data spots being recorded into the code.

QR Codes remind me of digital audio data printed onto 35mm film prints. Dolby Digital audio was printed in squares of data between the sprocket holes. There was a little Dolby logo in the middle of each data square -kind of like people sticking logos in the middle of QR Codes. Sony's digital audio format was printed on the edges of the film strip. DTS used a time code that looked like Morse code to sync the film print to audio being played on CD-ROM discs. The time code was printed to the right of the old optical analog stereo audio track. The old DTS format is still used on 70mm film presentations now; those modern 70mm prints only have time code and no other audio data on them.

 

[cornholio]

Hi, i made it like this.
Just create your code. Preferrably as vectors. Then shrink it so much, that the squares can be weeded together.
If you miss a couple, it's still much easier.

 

[Think713]

Hi, i made it like this.
Just create your code. Preferrably as vectors. Then shrink it so much, that the squares can be weeded together.
If you miss a couple, it's still much easier.
View attachment 182066

Why would you shrink it, if it has to be a certain size?
Just use the pathfinder tool and connect everything. This isnt a difficult thing to do.

 

[cornholio]

Why would you shrink it, if it has to be a certain size?
Just use the pathfinder tool and connect everything. This isnt a difficult thing to do.

Look at it, then you understand, how this helps weeding. (Just shrink the dark blocks a bit, so the weeding part hangs together. The overall geometry stays the same for recognition.

 

[FireSprint.com]

This might help with some of these ideas. I also explain some level of error correction:

 

[Think713]

Look at it, then you understand, how this helps weeding. (Just shrink the dark blocks a bit, so the weeding part hangs together. The overall geometry stays the same for recognition.

I would just use the pathfinder and make it all one shape... I dont see a need a shrink it. But if it works for you, great.

 

[cornholio]

I would just use the pathfinder and make it all one shape... I dont see a need a shrink it. But if it works for you, great.

It's for easier weeding. An inner square doesn't need to be picked out extra, it hangs on the other weeded form.

 

[Jean Shimp]

Problem solved...I sent the black and white image to the Vector Doctor. He sent me back a much-simplified file that was easy to weed. All the black boxes showed up as one solid box instead of multiple squares. I had to be careful weeding but the weed time and accuracy was much better. The overall size of the QR code is about 5x5". We are doing it in white vinyl and applying it to the outside of a glass door.